However, the company can specify a qualifying period of employment of upto five years. Provided that the minimum option period of three years is observed, there is no Income Tax charge on the grant or exercise of the option. Companies will receive Corporation Tax Relief on the cost of establishing and administering the scheme, and at the date on which shares are issued.
The option period must be between 3 and 10 years.
Income Tax and NI are not due when the option is granted or exercised, making this scheme very tax efficient, however, a potential barrier to its use lies in the fact that any options issued must be in the ultimate parent company of a group, and must be of the same class as those held by the group controllers, and will not be subject to any restrictions in terms of voting rights, etc.
The chief benefit of using an EMI Scheme is that no Income Tax or NI contributions are charged on the grant of EMI options, and, provided that i the exercise price is at least equal to the market value at the date of grant, and ii the options continue to qualify until the date of exercise which must be within ten years from the date of grant , then there will also be no Income Tax or NI charge at the point of exercise.
Any cash cancellation payment paid in lieu of exercising the options will not enjoy the same tax treatment and will be subject to Income Tax and NI. Further, if options are granted at a discount on the market value, then there will be an Income Tax charge on the difference between the actual price paid at the time of exercise and the market value at the date of grant, together with a likely NI charge.
As with the CSOP, the EMI scheme is discretionary, and the options have to be for ordinary, irredeemable and fully paid-up shares in the ultimate group parent company. Unlike the CSOP, there are various eligibility criteria that must be met by both the company and its employees in order to qualify for the EMI scheme.
Stock option planning: Generating value
Other restrictions also apply depending upon the activities of the business. For more information on this topic please see our separate Quick Guide found here. The name of the game is waiting, and how long you wait to sell your shares will determine if you trigger a qualifying or disqualifying disposition. This happens when you wait to sell shares acquired at least one year after you exercised your ISOs and at least two years after they were granted.
If a qualifying disposition is triggered, then any profits you make from the sale of your stock are taxed at long-term capital gains rates. And since long-term capital gains rates are lower than income tax rates, this is where you can realize the benefits of ISOs. If you fail to fulfill either of the waiting period requirements for a qualified disposition, then you have a disqualifying disposition and you lose the tax advantage of long-term capital gains rates. To compare the impact of a disqualifying disposition, let's use a similar fact pattern to the one above:.
Note that both the exercise date and the final sale date are different than those used to illustrate a qualifying disposition. In this example, we meet the first test for a qualifying disposition because the final sale date was more than two years from the grant date. When a disqualifying disposition is triggered, then the bargain element difference between FMV on exercise date and exercise price is taxed as regular income, and the difference between the FMV on the exercise date and the sale date is taxed as capital gain.
As for the capital gain, the rate you pay will depend on whether it is considered a long-term capital gain or a short-term capital gain. If held for at least a year, we meet the requirements for the more favorable long-term capital gains rates.
Primary Sidebar
If less than a year passed before the sale, then they are considered short-term capital gains and taxed as ordinary income. In our example, we held the shares for 10 months, so they are taxed as short-term capital gains. There are a lot of unknowns when it comes to stocks. Share prices go up and down all the time, so the longer you hold onto any amount of stock, the more you risk the share prices dropping. The hope is that when you decide to sell your shares, the fair market value of those shares has significantly increased.
A strategic approach that considers factors like your cash flow, tax implications and overall portfolio diversification will give you the best chance of seeing the benefit of ISOs. Your advisor can help you develop a strategy for how and when you want to exercise your options. The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. All investing involves risk including loss of principal.
No strategy assures success or protects against loss.
IRS Proposes to Tax Incentive Stock Options and Employee Stock Plans
Throughout his career Jim has helped clients with life planning, coaching them on how to help achieve their vision by leveraging their financial resources and focusing on work-life balance. Jim is This resource is continually monitored and revised for any necessary changes due to legal, market, or practice developments. Any significant developments affecting this resource will be described below.
What's on Practical Law? Show less Show more. Ask a question. Related Content. A Checklist outlining the requirements that must be satisfied for a stock option to qualify as an incentive stock option ISO under Section of the Internal Revenue Code and receive more favorable employee tax treatment than non-qualified stock options. An individual who exercises a non-qualified stock option must pay ordinary income taxes on the excess of the fair market value of the underlying shares on exercise over the exercise price the "spread".
However, ISOs are not subject to ordinary income taxes if the shares are held for both:.